A quintessential New England resort town, Montauk is one of the most popular places to vacation in New York. Known for its excellent beaches, scenic hiking trails, yacht clubs, and superb seafood, Montauk has everything you need for a fun weekend away!
Of course, in order to make your vacation successful, you need to find good accommodation. Montauk has plenty of hotels, but if you want a truly exceptional experience, it’s a good idea to check out options for unique accommodation in Montauk.
What sort of unique accommodation you might ask? Well, rest assured, because we’ve already done most of the work for you and put together this list of the best bed and breakfasts in Montauk that will fit any travel style, group size, and budget! Read on to begin planning your Montauk vacation.
In a Hurry? Here’s Where to Stay in Montauk for One Night
Sunrise Guest House
A beach-side property close to the Montauk village center, this charming bed and breakfast is the perfect place to enjoy the scenery and beaches of New England.
- Montauk Lighthouse
- Camp Hero
- Hither Hills State Park
Is this amazing Montauk Bed and Breakfast booked for your dates? We’ve got your back with our other favorite properties below!
Unlock Our GREATEST Travel Secrets!
Sign up for our newsletter and get the best travel tips delivered right to your inbox.
Staying at a Bed and Breakfast in Montauk
The Broke Backpacker is supported by you. Clicking through our links may earn us a small affiliate commission, and that's what allows us to keep producing free content 🙂 Learn more.
We all agree that travel is awesome, but it can also be stressful having to leave behind the comforts of home to explore a new place. One of the reasons bed and breakfasts are such good options is that they provide a more homey atmosphere coupled with great services so you can feel more comfortable during your vacation.
Since the beaches and seaside landscape is the crowning attraction of Montauk, many of the best bed and breakfasts are located right on the beach. From the famous lighthouse to gorgeous state parks, nothing is too far away in Montauk!
You can count on having your own private room in a bed and breakfast and most times you’ll also have access to common spaces including a living room, kitchen, and even the outdoor porch. Typically each room has a private bathroom, although some properties have shared bathrooms.
Most of the best bed and breakfasts you can stay at in Montauk include breakfast in the room price, although at some places it is a separate charge. If you have special dietary needs or want to save money and prepare your own meals, it’s easy to find a bed and breakfast with a kitchen available for guests.
What to Look for in a Bed and Breakfast
Location is everything when it comes to the best unique accommodation in Montauk! Many great bed and breakfast properties are located in the Montauk area itself, while others are nearby, either on the shores of Rhode Island or New York.
Depending on how much time you plan on spending in the area, you can check how far a property is from the airport or the top attractions you hope to visit. If you’re interested in having a beach holiday (let’s be honest, who isn’t), several bed and breakfasts have a seaside location.
It’s a good idea to confirm whether breakfast is offered and if so, is it included in the room price. Summer is peak travel season and during this time, some properties offer additional services that are unavailable during other times of the year.
If you’re a long-term traveler hoping to spend an extended period of time in the area, many bed and breakfasts in Montauk will offer weekly or monthly discounts, which can save you money in the long run. Airbnb and Booking.com are both great platforms to use to narrow your search and select a property available for your travel dates.
In general, at all of the best bed and breakfasts in Montauk, you can expect to find a great combination of relaxed beach vibes and traditional New England style which will captivate vacationers, photographers, and business travelers alike!
Sunrise Guest House
- > $$
- > 2 Guests
- > Exceptional hospitality
- > Beachfront location
The Big House
- > $
- > 2 Guests
- > Light and airy room
- > Indoor fireplace
Montauk Manor
- > $$$
- > 2 Guests
- > Full kitchen
- > Swimming pool
Block Island Inns
- > $$
- > 4 Guests
- > Private porch overlooking the sea
- > Spacious common areas
Southampton Center B&B
- > $$$$
- > 2 Guests
- > Superb breakfast
- > Outdoor terrace
Garden Gate B&B
- > $$
- > 4 Guests
- > Firepit and outdoor seating
- > Off-the-beaten-track
The Bellevue House
- > $
- > 2 Guests
- > Grill and picnic area
- > Awesome location
The Top 7 Bed and Breakfasts in Montauk
Now that you have an idea about what to expect when traveling the beautiful north New England coast, check out this list of options for where to stay; there’s everything from sweet luxury guesthouses to the best budget bed and breakfasts in Montauk!
Overall Best Bed and Breakfast in Montauk – Sunrise Guest House
Located within easy walking distance of Montauk village, the Sunrise Guesthouse gives you direct beach access and is ideally situated close to all the top attractions. Exploring the area is a lot more fun as you can rent bicycles from the property and start your adventure!
In your gorgeous room, you’ll have a private bathroom and TV, and you’ll start off each morning with a delicious breakfast which includes homemade treats. Our favorite part – Just stepping out the front door will take you directly to one of the most beautiful beaches of Montauk.
Want to save money on accommodation?
We got you. For reals.
Best Budget Bed and Breakfast in Montauk – The Big House
Located in New London, this historic bed and breakfast offers the perfect home-base to explore the New England area. You’ll have access to Amtrak service to Boston and New York, plus it’s easy to take a ferry to Montauk and other island destinations.
For a great price, you’ll have your own private room and free toiletries stocked in the bathroom. Plus the property has heating and air conditioning to keep the temperature comfortable no matter what time of year you visit.
Best Bed and Breakfast for Couples – Montauk Manor
For a romantic retreat with a touch of style and luxury, Montauk Manor is an excellent choice for accommodation. Centrally located, you’ll be right next to top Montauk attractions like the Montauk Golf courses and beaches.
Your private room has a full kitchen, TV, air conditioning and heating, and access to the two swimming pools and outdoor picnic area onsite. Plus, you can arrange fun activities like horseback riding, fishing, and hiking excursions right from reception!
Best Bed and Breakfast for a Group of Friends – Block Island Inns
A fun weekend escape with your friends can be made even better by staying at a charming beach house like Block Island Inn. Each private room has central heating and air conditioning, as well as a private bathroom with plenty of space for you and all your mates.
In addition to the complimentary breakfast, there’s afternoon wine and cookies for you to enjoy during your stay. There are plenty of beaches nearby, one of which is just a stone’s throw away. The best part of the day is sunset where you can relax on the wrap-around porch to take in the views.
We’ve tested countless backpacks over the years, but there’s one that has always been the best and remains the best buy for adventurers: the broke backpacker-approved Osprey Aether and Ariel series.
Want more deetz on why these packs are so damn perfect? Then read our comprehensive review for the inside scoop!
View on Osprey View on REIOver-the-Top Luxury Bed and Breakfast – Southampton Center B&B
Just a mile away from the gorgeous beaches of New England, this Southampton B&B is the perfect spot to treat yourself to a luxurious experience! You’ll have a stunning private room and bathroom all to yourself, plus access to the kitchen, comfy living space, and the beautiful outdoor garden.
There’s free parking onsite and it’s only a short drive to Montauk and other great beach destinations, as well as shopping centers and restaurants. The quiet neighborhood is a great place to walk, and it’s only a few blocks from the Southampton center.
Best Bed and Breakfast for Families visiting Montauk – Garden Gate B&B
A great home-away-from-home for the entire family, the Garden Gate B&B has a private room and bathroom, plus great communal spaces including a shared kitchenette, dining room, and an outdoor shower house.
Every morning you can start your day off with a hearty breakfast that’s prepared using fresh local ingredients and if you have special dietary needs, just let the hosts know and they’ll do their best to accommodate you. Plus, beach chairs and umbrellas are provided so you can keep your suitcases lighter when traveling.
Best Bed and Breakfast for Backpackers – The Bellevue House
Located in New Shoreham just a short ferry ride away from Montauk and other New England beach destinations, the Bellevue House offers reasonably priced accommodation in a beautifully renovated historic Inn.
During the summer months, you can enjoy a delicious homemade breakfast for an additional fee and there are plenty of restaurants and shops nearby to pick up provisions. At the end of the day, relax on the outdoor picnic furniture or watch your favorite movies on the TV in your room.
Check out these other great resources
We have loads more information to help you plan your trip.
FAQ about Bed and Breakfast in Montauk
Here’s what people usually ask us when they look for vacation homes in Montauk.
Don’t Forget Your Montauk Travel Insurance
ALWAYS sort out your backpacker insurance before your trip. There’s plenty to choose from in that department, but a good place to start is Safety Wing.
They offer month-to-month payments, no lock-in contracts, and require absolutely no itineraries: that’s the exact kind of insurance long-term travellers and digital nomads need.
SafetyWing is cheap, easy, and admin-free: just sign up lickety-split so you can get back to it!
Click the button below to learn more about SafetyWing’s setup or read our insider review for the full tasty scoop.
Final Thoughts on Bed and Breakfast in Montauk
From the high-end luxury of the Hamptons to cute, tiny seaside cottages, the Montauk region is one of the most popular vacation destinations in New England. Whether you’re just visiting for a weekend or planning a whole summer retreat, staying at one of the best bed and breakfasts in Montauk is a way to guarantee your experience is fun and authentic!
Even if you’re traveling with a big family or you only have a small budget, it’s still possible to find cool unique accommodation in Montauk. Now that you’ve gone through our list, all that’s left to do is make a reservation to set your beach vacation into motion.
Buy Us a Coffee!
A couple of you lovely readers suggested we set up a tip jar for direct support as an alternative to booking through our links. So we created one!
You can now buy The Broke Backpacker a coffee. If you like and use our content to plan your trips, it’s a much appreciated way to show appreciation 🙂
